Company name Republic Airways Holdings Inc.
Stock ticker RJET
Live stock price [stckqut]RJET[/stckqut]
Confident Investor Rating Poor

The following company description is from Google Finance: http://www.google.com/finance?q=rjet

Republic Airways Holdings Inc. is a holding company. The Company offers scheduled passenger services through its wholly-owned operating air carrier subsidiaries: Chautauqua Airlines, Inc. (Chautauqua), Shuttle America Corporation (Shuttle), Republic Airline Inc. (Republic Airline) and Frontier Airlines, Inc. (Frontier). As of December 31, 2011, its operating subsidiaries offered scheduled passenger service on 1,483 flights daily to 132 cities in 42 states, Canada, Mexico, and Costa Rica under Frontier operations as Frontier and through fixed-fee code-share agreements with AMR Corp., the parent of American Airlines, Inc. (American), Continental Airlines, Inc. (Continental), Delta Air Lines, Inc. (Delta), United Air Lines, Inc. (United), and US Airways, Inc. (US Airways). The Company took delivery of eight A320 aircraft, two E190 aircraft, placed into service three A319 aircraft, sold five A318 aircraft, four of which have remained in the fleet under sale leaseback agreements.
Confident Investor comments: At this price and at this time, I do not think that a Confident Investor can confidently invest in this stock. It is not possible to confidently invest in a company that is not currently profitable.

If you would like to understand how to evaluate companies like I do on this site, please read my book, The Confident Investor.

Let’s say you were around on VJ day, September 2, 1945, which was the day that Japan formally surrendered at the end of World War II. For the month of September 1945, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was at $180. Sixty years later in September 2005, the DJIA was $4,789. That is an increase of over 2600% over 60 years.

The problem is that the increase in the DJIA was not a straight line; it went up and down the entire time. If you could not wait for 60 years but only had 40 years, the price in September 1985 was $1,329, which is only a bit better than 700% for the four decades. If you only could wait 20 years, the price in September 1965 was $931, which was a bit better than a 500% increase.

How does this compare to interest earned in a bank? If you put $180 into a bank account and it earns 8.22% compounded daily for 20 years, then you will have about $931 (the same value as the DJIA that year). For 40 years, the $180 invested at 5% would result in your $1,329. The 60 year mark would turn your $180 into $4792 at 5.47%. This shows that the timing of your buying and selling can have a dramatic impact on the return of that investment.

“Buy and hold” may be good, but it does not necessarily mean that the longer you hold your investment, the wealthier you will become! This is due to the erratic nature of the stock market. You need a system that can maximize the return during the peaks and minimize the risk on the valleys. Five to eight percent returns seem quite small, especially for something as high-risk as the stock market.

Five to eight percent returns are probably adequate for a bank, but this is not a safe, FDIC-insured bank. This is a highly-volatile holding that can decline in value quite rapidly. Conservative banks can pay a lower interest rate because the saver can be assured that the rate of return is safe. In the stock market, your only stability comes from your understanding of what is happening to your investment.

You need a system that allows you to evaluate companies, buy into those companies that are good investments, and then transfer that money to other companies when the investment is better elsewhere. That system is described in my book, The Confident Investor. You can purchase my book wherever books are sold such as AmazonBarnes and Noble, and Books A Million. It is available in ebook formats for NookKindle, and iPad.

Company name The Procter & Gamble Company
Stock ticker PG
Live stock price [stckqut]PG[/stckqut]
P/E compared to competitors Good

MANAGEMENT EXECUTION

Employee productivity Good
Sales growth Poor
EPS growth Poor
P/E growth Fair
EBIT growth Poor

ANALYSIS

Confident Investor Rating Poor
Target stock price (TWCA growth scenario) $57.89
Target stock price (averages with growth) $68.68
Target stock price (averages with no growth) $63.55
Target stock price (manual assumptions) $88.95

The following company description is from Google Finance: http://www.google.com/finance?q=pg

The Procter & Gamble Company (P&G), is focused on providing consumer packaged goods. The Company’s products are sold in more than 180 countries primarily through mass merchandisers, grocery stores, membership club stores, drug stores and high-frequency stores. As of June 30, 2012, P&G was organized into two Global Business Units (GBUs): Beauty and Grooming and Household Care. The GBUs contain a total of five segments: Beauty; Grooming; Health Care; Fabric Care and Home Care and Baby Care and Family Care. Sales to Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. and the affiliates represent approximately 14% of the total revenue during the fiscal year ended June 30, 2012 (fiscal 2012). On December 30, 2011, Helen of Troy Ltd. acquired PUR water purification products business (PUR) from the Company. Effective June 1, 2012, P&G announced that it has completed the sale of the Pringles business to Kellogg Company.

 

Confident Investor comments: At this price and at this time, I do not think that a Confident Investor can confidently invest in this stock.

If you would like to understand how to evaluate companies like I do on this site, please read my book, The Confident Investor.

I probably could have titled this article, “Why I am concerned with companies that give dividends” since I feel these subjects are intertwined. When a company gives a dividend but doesn’t have a large sum of money going into corporate R&D, I am very concerned about the long-term health of that company. A company dividend is basically saying that the managers of the company cannot think of anything better to do with the money than to give it back to the shareholders. While I have nothing against getting a check from my portfolio companies, I don’t want that check to starve future product development that could make the company even more profit in the future.

It isn’t difficult to measure R&D but it is sometimes difficult to measure its effectiveness. To measure R&D, you should use one or both of the following techniques.

  • PRR (Price to Research) – This is the market value of the company divided by its research-and-development expenditure over the last twelve months. Look for companies with PRRs between five and 10 and avoid companies with PRRs greater than 15. By looking for low PRRs, investors should be able to spot companies that are redirecting current profits into R&D, thereby better ensuring long-term future returns.
  • Price/Growth Flow Model – Price/growth flow attempts to identify companies that are producing solid current earnings while simultaneously investing a lot of money into R&D. To calculate the growth flow, simply take the R&D of the last 12 months and divide it by the shares outstanding to get R&D per share. Add this to the company’s EPS and divide by the share price.

It is far more difficult to look at the effectiveness of R&D. One way, is to calculate the percentage of sales that come from products introduced over the preceding three years. For the calculation, investors need annual sales information for specific new products and this can sometimes be difficult to find. Sometimes, the investor simply has to read the annual report and take note of the CEO or Chairman comments on new product introductions – a lack of conversation often means a lack of products.

Finally, be careful to not overly reward high R&D industries. For example, the pharmaceutical industry spends a huge amount in R&D due to the nature of its market. Just like P/E analysis that I explain in my book, The Confident Investor, R&D spending needs to be compared among its peer group.

If you are amazed at the high dividend given by a company, take a look at their PRR or Price/Growth Flow.  How does that compare to its peer group?  If it is not keeping up then that dividend could actually be starving the long-term potential of the company.

Company name Baytex Energy Corp (USA)
Stock ticker BTE
Live stock price [stckqut]BTE[/stckqut]
P/E compared to competitors Good

MANAGEMENT EXECUTION

Employee productivity Good
Sales growth Fair
EPS growth Good
P/E growth Good
EBIT growth Good

ANALYSIS

Confident Investor Rating Good
Target stock price (TWCA growth scenario) $72.44
Target stock price (averages with growth) $54.19
Target stock price (averages with no growth) $27.45
Target stock price (manual assumptions) $63.98

The following company description is from Google Finance: http://www.google.com/finance?q=bte

Baytex Energy Corp. (Baytex), through its subsidiaries, are engaged in the business of acquiring, developing, exploiting and holding interests in petroleum and natural gas properties and related assets in Canada (in the provinces of British Columbia, Alberta and Saskatchewan) and in the United States (in the states of North Dakota and Wyoming). On February 3, 2011, the Company acquired heavy oil assets located in the Reno area of northern Alberta and the Lloydminster area of western Saskatchewan. On August 9, 2011, the Company acquired natural gas assets located in the Brewster area of west central Alberta. During the year ended December 31, 2011, it completed two dispositions of undeveloped lands; in the Kaybob South area of west central Alberta, it sold six sections of leasehold, including five sections with Duvernay rights, and in the Dodsland area in southwest Saskatchewan, which it sold 32,600 net acres of leasehold in the halo of the field.

 

Confident Investor comments: At this price and at this time, I think that a Confident Investor can confidently invest in this stock.

If you would like to understand how to evaluate companies like I do on this site, please read my book, The Confident Investor.